Save big on select digital products!

What To Send Your Email List When You Have Nothing To Sell

Gizella Nagyne Palinkas

9/17/20266 min read

Send one of four things: something useful, a story, a recommendation, or an ask. Most people believe an email is only allowed to exist when there is something to sell, which is why their list hears from them twice a year and has forgotten who they are by the time it does. An email has four possible jobs and selling is only one of them. The other three are what make the fourth one welcome when it finally arrives. Pick a job before you open the draft, and the blank page problem disappears.

That is the whole answer. The rest explains why it works and gives you a month you can copy.

Why silence costs more than a mediocre email

The instinct to stay quiet feels considerate. It is not, and the reason is mechanical.

Inbox providers do not evaluate your writing. They evaluate behaviour: whether people open, reply, move you out of promotions, or mark you as spam. A list that hears from you on a rhythm accumulates a record of people who want you there. A list that hears from you twice a year accumulates nothing, so when you finally send, the provider has no recent evidence to work with.

Google is unusually explicit about the standard it applies. Its email sender guidelines tell bulk senders to keep spam complaint rates below 0.1% and to prevent them from ever reaching 0.3%. The same guidelines require SPF, DKIM and DMARC authentication, one-click unsubscribe on promotional mail under RFC 8058, and recommend honouring unsubscribe requests within 48 hours.

Note the shape of that incentive. Complaint rate is a ratio, and a list that has not heard from you in months produces more complaints per send, because more recipients have forgotten signing up. Sporadic sending is the risky behaviour, not regular sending.

The four jobs an email can do

Job one: teach one thing completely

Teach one thing, completely. Not five things partially.

The common mistake is writing the email as a trailer for something longer, so it ends on a link and the reader learns nothing by reading it. Reverse that. If someone read only your email and clicked nothing, they should be able to do something today they could not do yesterday. Four hundred words is plenty.

Job two: tell a story

People skip this one because it feels self-indulgent. It is not. A story is how a reader works out whether your judgement is worth borrowing, and borrowed judgement is the basis on which anyone later takes a recommendation from you.

The shape is simple: something happened, here is what I thought at the time, here is what I think now. No moral required. The reader draws it.

Job three: point at something you did not make

The cheapest email to write, because somebody else did the work. Three things you read this month and the one sentence each changed for you. A tool you stopped using and why.

People worry this sends readers away. It does the reverse. Filtering a noisy field is a real service, and the fastest way to become useful before you have anything of your own to offer.

Job four: the ask

Two rules. Say clearly what the thing is, and say who it is not for. Most people omit the second half, and it is the half that earns belief, because a reader told who should skip something trusts you about who should not.

The ask needs no apology in front and no countdown behind. It needs the other three jobs behind it, so it reads as a continuation rather than an ambush.

Cadence: pick a pace you can hold on a bad week

The exact frequency matters far less than whether it is a rhythm.

Weekly is easier to sustain than monthly, which sounds wrong until you have tried both. Weekly means you never have to decide whether this week counts. Monthly means every send carries the weight of being the only one, so you overthink it, postpone it, and it quietly becomes never.

Choose the pace you could manage on a bad week, not a good one.

Subject lines: the first half of a sentence

Stop writing headlines. Start writing the first half of a sentence somebody wants finished.

Not "The five pillars of great email." Try "I deleted the welcome sequence." Or "This took me four years to notice."

Specific and unfinished beats clever and complete, because clever announces that marketing is happening and specific sounds like a person. Keep it short enough to survive a phone screen, truncated, read by someone doing something else.

The reply is the metric

This is the part that reorganises everything else.

Open rate has become close to meaningless as a measure of interest. Apple's Mail Privacy Protection pre-loads remote images for Apple Mail users whether or not the message was read, inflating reported opens; Mailchimp's documentation explains the effect and advises against treating open rate as a reliable comparison metric.

The reply is not subject to that problem. When someone writes back, three things happen at once. The provider observes a genuine two-way exchange. You learn, in their words, what they are stuck on. And a stranger becomes a correspondent.

So end emails with a question that can be answered honestly in one line, and then reply to the people who reply to you.

Keep a file of the replies

Not a system. A plain document. Every time somebody writes back with a question, paste it in.

Within six weeks you are looking at the thing most people claim to want and almost nobody builds: a list of problems written in the exact language of the people who have them. Your next email is in that file, and so is whatever you make next, described by the people who would use it, before you have built anything.

If content planning is the harder part, Content Strategy 101 covers the same decision at wider scope.

A worked month you can copy

Week one — useful. One small, complete thing. Roughly four hundred words. Ends in a question.
Week two — story. Something that happened, what you thought then, what you think now. Same invitation to reply.
Week three — signal. Three things worth their attention, one line each on why.
Week four — the ask, if you have something. If you do not, another useful one.

Three parts giving, one part asking, repeating. You never open a blank draft wondering what the email is for, because the calendar has already decided.

"But I will annoy them"

Some people will unsubscribe. An unsubscribe is a correction, not a rejection. That person was not going to be your reader, and every week they stayed they made your numbers less true. Given that complaint rate is the ratio providers actually watch, a list that quietly shrinks while the remaining readers open and reply is in better condition than one that stays large and silent.

The silence you are protecting is not politeness. It is a slower goodbye.

If your list has already gone cold

Do not open with an apology tour. One line of housekeeping is enough: it has been a while, here is what I have been doing, here is something useful. Then the useful thing. Send it to everyone, including the quiet ones, because you cannot know who is still there until you knock.

When you do have something to sell

The structure barely changes. Announce it once in a normal email. A few days later, send one that is useful on its own and mentions the thing at the bottom. Near the end, a short one saying only what it is, who it is for and who should skip it.

Three touches, not eleven. The people who do not want it are not worn down by the twelfth, they leave, and every email afterwards goes to a smaller and more tired room. For the sequences written out in order, that is what the E-Mail Marketing Playbook is for.

Frequently asked questions

How long should an email be? Long enough to finish one idea. Four hundred words is a good working default for a useful email. Length is not the variable that matters; completeness is.

What if I only have thirty subscribers? Then you can write to them as thirty individual people, which is an advantage you will never have again. Small lists reply at rates large lists do not.

How do I know if it is working if open rates are unreliable? Count replies and count unsubscribes. Both are behaviours the recipient chose deliberately, which is exactly what makes them readable.

What if I miss a week? Send the next one without mentioning it. A missed week is visible only to you.

Start here

If the honest problem is that there is barely a list to write to yet, fix that first.

How to Build an Email List From Scratch covers where the sign-up goes, what you offer in exchange, and how to get the first hundred people on it without an audience. Free and complete. No upsell at the end.